by Abu Khuzaimah Ansaari
Madkhalism is a vile concocted term and in fact those who uses are not even aware of its actual meaning or what it entails. I will be inshaAllaah adding further notes to the statement of Imaam Dhahabee (see the statement below) from his own books with the intent of adding more understanding to it. Suffice it to say it has nothing to do with Madkhalism and rather comprehension issues or concept revolving around emotional outburst. No doubt this seems like an error and we pray that people refrain from using ambiguous statements like this and applying them to ideas they understand themselves or a lack of them for that matter and then fitting them on to terms like madkhalism.
Shaikh Rabee (Hafidhahullah) said
Shaikh Rabee also said
Another example of Shaikh Rabee’s dawah
Shaikh Rabees way of Dawah
I say the words of Shaikh Rabee below inshaAllaah shall aid in explanation of the statement of Imaam Dhahabee. (and REMEMBER we make taqleed of no one except follow the Quraan and Sunnah and this known about us for last 17 years and even THEY say this about us!!!)
The first video destroys this alleged tearing apart and we have not even gone to the extensive statements of Imaam Dhahabee. So how is this tearing up Madkhalism !!!! BENEFICIAL NOTE Shaikh Rabee talks about the general people in the first video and the statement below is generically general and refers to the Imaams of AHLUS SUNNAH. More comprehension in second part.
Where is the balance, we should be balanced and not fall into things which others do.
part 2 coming soon inshaAllaah and more
Imaam al-Jarh wat Ta’deel Ameer ul-Mu’mineen fir-Rijaal wal Hadeeth, Shams ud-Deen Adh-Dhahabi tearing the whole Madkhalism apart inside out!
Imam al-Dhahabi said: And if—every time an Imaam made a mistake in his ijtihaad in some issues which he can be forgiven in—we rose up against him and declared him to be an innovator, and boycotted him, then Ibn Nasr would not be safe with us, nor Ibn Mandah, and nor people greater than both of them. And Allaah is the One who guides the creation to the Truth, and He is the Most Merciful of those who show mercy, and we seek refuge with Allaah from desires and coarseness.” And he said, “Thereafter, verily, when the issues that a great scholar from the people of knowledge is correct in are numerous, and his striving to come to the truth is known, and his knowledge is vast, and his intelligence has become apparent, and his righteousness and his following [the Quran and the Sunnah] is known, he is forgiven for making a mistake—and we do not declare him to be misguided, nor do we throw him aside and forget his good deeds … yes, and we do not follow him in his innovation or mistake and we hope that he will repent from that.” (Siyar A’laam an-Nubalaa, 14/40 and 5/271)